Back to Inside Russsia and Eurasia home page
  HELP   webmaster



Extension of the refugee crisis
From Syria to the Caucasus
Report - 21 September 2015
print this material
The exodus from Syria is having a little-noticed effect on the Caucasus and some Russian republics NEW
By Nina Bachkatov and Andrew Wilson

At a recent press conference (10 Sep) President Putin’s spokesman, Dmitri Peskov, declared that although the Middle East refugee crisis was not a problem for Russia, it had seen attempts to use its territory as a transit route to countries of the European Union.

As he saw it, the weight of the crisis has to be born by those countries and people whose actions had contributed to the destabilisation of North Africa and the Middle East..

At the same time, Russia is not immune to refugee crises generally. Already almost a tenth of its population consisted of legal and illegal migrants, mostly from former Soviet republics, whose presence put it at the top of the league as an international shelter.

But here Peskov was speaking of a specific crisis from which Russia is not completely sheltered, if only because official estimates speak of 2,500 Russians fighting on the side of ISIS.

Moreover, Moscow is facing a challenge from the Middle East crisis that is on a different scale, and with potential repercussions, from those in Europe. Witness two different cases, both in a region of strategic importance for the Kremlin.

The Circassians

On 10 September, the agency RIA Novosti quoted the head of the republic of Kabarda-Balkaria as saying that ‘several thousand refugees from Syria had been welcomed’ in the southern Russian republic - a statement that followed similar ones by the heads of other small republics of North Caucasus, notably Adygea and Cherkassia.

In fact, the refugees are Syrian Circassians who decided to escape from the fighting in Syria by going back to the country of their ancestors, who long ago retreated with the Ottoman forces at the end of the Russian-Turkish wars.

Their return, saluted as a sign of attachment to their motherland, carries a price. Not all the refugees are coming with the means by which to start a small business or a farm. Consequently the already poor republics are having to provide housing, schools, social and medical aid.

The influx also carries the risk of altering the fragile ethnic, religious and clan balance of the entire region. This involves no trivial matters such as going back to the first arrival in 2012 to discuss the choice of languages in which to teach them: Kabar, Balkar, Adygei or just universally Russian.

On the top of that, Moscow can hardly forget that during the preparations for the 2014 Sochi Winter Olympics in 2014 there were attempts to internationalise the question of recognising the ‘Circiassian genocide’ – an argument raised by opponents of the Games, knowing how their success was important for president Putin.


A louder alarm has been raised in Baku with the arrival of Syrian Armenians in the land of their forbearers – bearing in mind that Armenia is mentioned as a threat to Azerbaijan’s security in its doctrine.

Armenia’s foreign policy has always put an emphasis on good relations with Middle Eastern countries, especially Lebanon and Syrian, both of which shelter an important Armenian Diaspora. Good relations with Syria were evidenced when, in 2009, Syrian President Bashar al-Assad made an official visit to Armenia and signed numerous co-operation agreements ‘based on centuries-long friendship between the Armenian and Syrian peoples’.

Then came the war in Syria, and by November 2012 Armenian foreign minister Edward Nalbandian was talking of the arrival from Syria of ‘thousands of refugees of Armenian descent’. A year later, after a brief calm, the flow restarted on a larger scale, thanks to the resumption of the direct Beirut-Yerevan flights and bus services.

Mounting number

According to the Minister of Diaspora, Hranush Hakobian, at the end of 2013 about 200 Syrian Armenians were arriving in Armenia weekly, and there already were over 10,000 in the country. The increase is due to the fact that Syrian Armenians, who would earlier have prefer to go to Beirut, switched for Armenia where they were guaranteed state support, a Christian society, civil peace and the possibility to receiving education.

With their number growing, as well as the cost and the competition for jobs, Yerevan began to resettle refugees in Nagorno-Karabakh, which has plenty of space including for families coming from rural Syrian districts. But in Baku, this was seen as a further sign that Armenia is not only regularly violating the 1994 cease-fire but also was making another attempt to create a de facto ‘armenianisation’ of the ‘occupied territories’ that had been ethnically cleared of Azeris during the war.

According to official Baku sources, 11.000 Armenians migrants have been settled in Nagorno-Karabkh, nearly 10% of its official population.

Not surprisingly, the authorities have responded with bellicose declarations, under pressure of an opposition always quick to use the Nagorno Karabakh card against president Aliev. Even if it remains on the level of verbal exchanges, this can only delay further a settlement of one of the main crises destabilising the South Caucasus.

21 September 2015
print this material

Matériel connexe sur Russia
Lukashenko the survivor –
  By will, and by skill
  (8 October 2015)

Russia and Syria
  Confronting Isis
  (17 September 2015)

Russia and the Greek crisis
  Staying on the sideline
  (17 July 2015)

The EU and Russia
  Far apart on energy needs
  (28 April 2015)

Russia and the Gulf
  Not the Soviet Union
  (24 April 2015)

Russia and Yemen
  Wisdom and Neutrality
  (11 April 2015)

Collective woes of the 'FSU' (2)
  Seven states in crisis
  (10 March 2015)

Russia’s defence spending under pressur
  Russian and Kiev forces compared
  (6 March 2015)

Russia’s ‘opposition’
  How to regain momentum
  (1 March 2015)

en savoir plus sur Russia...

Matériel connexe sur Armenia
The Riga summit
  Time to wake up
  (20 May 2015)

Collective woes of the 'FSU' (1)
  Seven states in crisis
  (11 March 2015)

Caucasus and Karabakh
  Washington’s too hasty quest
  (18 July 2010)

Armenia, Turkey and Russia
  ‘Yerevan losing to Ankara’ allegation
  (11 September 2009)

Turkey ‘no proxy’
  Snag to Armenia and NKO hopes
  (19 May 2009)

Washington lobbies
  Rooting for NATO enlargement
  (15 May 2009)

Settling Nagorno-Karabakh
  The perils of haste
  (2 December 2008)

Fevered Transcaucasia
  In the grip of the Kosovo effect
  (12 March 2008)

Armenia’s presidential election
  Kosovo helped the result
  (21 February 2008)

en savoir plus sur Armenia...

Matériel connexe sur Azerbaijan
Azerbaijan under scrutiny
  European Games in the Caucasus
  (10 June 2015)

The Riga summit
  Time to wake up
  (20 May 2015)

Electing Azerbaijan's president
  Geopolitical pragmatism
  (2 October 2013)

Eurovision contest turns political
  Unscrpted song and dance in Baku
  (27 April 2012)

Caucasus and Karabakh
  Washington’s too hasty quest
  (18 July 2010)

Turkey ‘no proxy’
  Snag to Armenia and NKO hopes
  (19 May 2009)

Settling Nagorno-Karabakh
  The perils of haste
  (2 December 2008)

Armenia and Azerbaijan
  The unbreakable deadlock
  (26 December 2006)

Azerbaijanis caught in a vortex
  As President Bush weighs strikes on Iran
  (17 September 2006)

en savoir plus sur Azerbaijan...

Matériel connexe sur North Caucasus
Volgograd bombings
  A threat to Sochi?
  (7 January 2014)

Georgia and the Chechens
   An old trail revisited
  (22 May 2013)

Moscow airport bombing
  Time to recognise the reality of terror
  (26 January 2011)

Troubled North Caucasus
  A typical day
  (22 July 2010)

Russia’s 'new terrorism’
  Behind the Metro bombings
  (29 March 2010)

Russia's identity problem
  From Chechnya to the Vertical of Power
  (21 July 2008)

North Caucasus
  An unvarnished picture
  (13 February 2006)